Debate Harris v. Pence: the verdict of our experts

Five columnists from Newspaper present their analysis of the debate between Democratic Senator Kamala Harris and US Vice President Mike Pence during the presidential campaign.

• Read also: Kamala Harris and Mike Pence offer a real debate

Pierre Martin

A face-to-face meeting that will quickly be forgotten

Kamala Harris and Mike Pence have neither lost nor gained ground.

The two carefully avoided answering a bunch of questions, but Pence was supremely irritating with his grimaces, interruptions, and consistently going over his speaking times.

He was repeating Donald Trump’s usual lies, including his phantom health plan and his imaginary environmental accomplishments.

Harris attacked Trump’s catastrophic pandemic record, but she could have done more. This debate will quickly be forgotten.

Loïc Tassé

Harris, hands down

Kamala Harris was smiling, informed, concrete, intelligent.

It rebounded well on several topics, such as Donald Trump’s finances or the way the president talks about American soldiers who died in combat.

The only subject where it was weaker: China.

Mike Pence was dull, spread himself out in banalities, constantly ran over time, very often avoided answering questions, for example on climate change.

Harris was also able to set the record straight on several occasions.

Normand Lester

Mission accomplished for Harris

Kamala Harris has been persuasive in her case over the Trump administration’s incompetence and inconsistency particularly around the coronavirus crisis. She also had to show that she was a woman who had the skills to become president. Mission accomplished !

Mike Pence politely tried to defend the indefensible: his handling of the coronavirus crisis and Trump’s erratic four years in the White House.

A generally calm debate, without scandal which will allow voters to decide which of the two is more apt to replace, in the short term, elderly presidents with declining health.

Luc Laliberté

The adult debate

If Kamala Harris were to prove his reputation is not overrated, Mike Pence had to contend with a mixed record in handling the pandemic and a president who has been rampaging on social media for two days.

Well prepared and in control, Harris and Pence delivered the goods, each successfully completing their assignments.

The Democrat had to avoid hurting her candidate, Joe Biden, who holds an interesting lead, while Pence had to score points.

But if the truth and the facts are to be considered, the Democratic candidate must be given the advantage.

Richard Latendresse

The bar was low

Finally a normal debate! Littered with exaggerations, falsehoods, twisted allegations, true and false emotions, but at least no one called the other a clown.

Never has an outgoing vice-president had to cross such a low bar in a political debate: to appear vaguely coherent and thoughtful.

Mike Pence rose to the challenge; better yet, by being courteous, he rocked the image of a misogynistic White House sticking to his boss’s skin.

Kamala Harris was to represent the Americans who have already forgotten the debates of the Democratic primary. She was knowledgeable and assertive, while remaining calm. It didn’t hurt Joe Biden’s campaign, that’s the bottom line.

Because Mike Pence continues to live in the alternate reality nurtured by President Trump, victory in Harris!

Civilized exchanges

“The American people have witnessed what is the greatest failure of any presidential administration in the history of our country. “–Kamala Harris

“China is to blame for the coronavirus, and Donald Trump is not happy. “– Mike Pence, pointing out the authorities’ slowness to sound the alarm

“Mr. Vice-President, I’m speaking. I speak. “–Kamala Harris, when Mike Pence tried to interrupt

“I am pro-life and I won’t apologize for that. “– Mike Pence

“When I look at the plan [pour la COVID-19] from Biden, it looks a bit like plagiarism; what Joe Biden knows. – Mike Pence

“Joe Biden was a cheerleader for Communist China”– Mike Pence

Pierre MartinLoïc TasséNormand LesterLuc LalibertéRichard LatendresseAVERAGE
Kamala harris8/109/108/107.5 / 107/107.9 /10
Mike pence6/105/106/107/106/106/10

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *